
I don’t know if Mary Agnes Welch is being played like a fool by some lobbyists and entrepreneurs, or if she’s got a hate on for the NDP but today brings us yet another classical smear against Manitoba Hydro and the Manitoba government.
In today’s episode, the government is negligent because private sector energy companies that build windmills are not building them fast enough.
Welch notes that the NDP government in Manitoba has promised to install 1,000 megawatts of wind power by 2015. She also notes that there are nine wind farms, totaling 1,100 megawatts of power that have received environmental licences, but have been shelved.
Justin Rangooni, a paid lobbyist for the windmill companies, (i.e. the Ontario Policy Manager for the Canadian Wind Energy Association), claims that things are at a standstill in Manitoba.
To paint an even starker picture, Welch goes to another private sector interest, in this case a rep from a company called Total Wind Canada Inc.
“We put our company here hoping St. Joseph would be up and running, but it’s been three years,” said Purkess. “What is it that’s holding us back in Manitoba while every other province is going heavy and hard.”
Does Welch get her to elaborate? Give her opinion as to why things are being held back in Manitoba? I mean, she has the company rep on the phone. Why not ask?
Ahhh, but why ask when it’s better to infer. That’s real reporting going on here folks.
Rangooni and Welch go on to paint the picture that all of the windmill development is going to Ontario because the government there has streamlined the approval process and is offering to pay a guaranteed price of 13.5 cents per kilowatt hour.
“Ontario has a new green energy policy called a feed-in tariff that threatens to suck all the wind out of Manitoba. It’s a guaranteed, set price – 13.5 cents per kilowatt hours – the province of Ontario will pay for wind power. Any company that can link to the grid, get environmental approvals and a contract with the power company will earn that price, a healthy one.”
Wait, what?
If nine projects totaling 1,100 megawatts of power, a number that exceeds the target of 1,000 megawatts, have received approval for construction here in Manitoba, but have not been constructed – well, that would mean that the approval process is not a fault here.
So what is preventing these companies from going, “heavy and hard” like our friend from Total Wind Canada Inc claims is happening in other provinces?
Maybe it’s the money, or lack thereof and the maturity, or lack thereof, of the windmill industry, and the recession.
Aim PowerGen is purported to be developing the Dominion City Wind Energy Project and the Oakland Wind Energy Project. Aim PowerGen was just sold from Renewable Energy Generation Limited to International Power plc.
Greenwing Energy Development is reported as building the Yellowhead Wind Energy Project and the Reston Wind Energy Project. Just last year, GreenWing Energy Development Limited Partnership was sold to Altagas.
PPM which is in charge of the 300 megawatt Mountain Energy Project as recently acquired by Iberdrola Renewables.
And Sequioa Energy of Manitoba is in charge of the Meridian Wind Energy Project, the Killarney Wind Energy Project and the Pembina Hills Wind Energy Project.
All of this upheaval coupled with difficulties raising investment capital during a global recession is bound to slow things down. Why aren’t these questions posed to the lobbyists and private interests? Why are their allegations taken; and statements printed at face value?
But in the final analysis, it comes down to what we Manitobans should pay for power.
We currently pay about 6 cents per kilowatt hour for our Hydro electricity for residential purposes and it’s even less for industrial or corporate consumers. So, if Ontario is paying 13.5 cents per kilowatt hour, well one doesn’t have to be a rocket surgeon to figure this out.
Does this mean that Manitoba Hydro should buy the power at 13.5 cents per kilowatt hour and sell it for 6 cents?
Or does it mean that we should all pay 13.5 cents per kilowatt hour instead of the 6 or so that we’re currently paying?
I would suggest that the problem here lay not with the processes for the approval of windmill licences, afterall, all nine projects have received approval.
If you want to pay double your current Hydro rates, then perhaps we could follow Ontario’s lead and subsidize the private sector.
Or, perhaps we could recognize that we are blessed with clean, cheap power here and if the private sector wants to compete, then they will have to become more efficient.






